The future of a young Christian girl has taken a heartbreaking turn after a court decision allowed her to remain with a man her family said had abducted and forcibly converted her, raising deep concerns among Pakistan’s Christian community.

Maria Shahbaz was taken from her home in July. Her family said she was kidnapped, forced to convert to Islam, and married against her will. For months, her parents fought to bring her back, but the court’s decision has shattered their hope.

On March 25, Pakistan’s Federal Constitutional Court declared that Maria is of “mature age” and can legally remain with the man her family accuses of abducting her. The court validated her conversion and ruled that the marriage is governed by Islamic law. Muslim men are permitted to marry women from Ahl al-Kitab (People of the Book), including Christians, and use this as a basis to uphold the marriage.

For Maria’s father, Shahbaz Masih, the decision feels like losing his daughter all over again.

Maria’s father told the court she was 12 or 13 at the time and presented documents to prove it. Judges deemed the records unreliable, saying her appearance suggested she was older.

The court stated that in Islam, conversion requires only a declaration of faith, not a formal ceremony. Maria’s conversion was therefore accepted as genuine.

But many are asking: can a child, taken from her home and kept away from her family, truly make such a choice freely?

Christian leaders and rights groups said this case reflects a broader pattern in Pakistan, with minority girls allegedly abducted, pressured to convert, and married to Muslim men.

“These girls are often isolated and afraid,” a rights advocate said. “When they speak in court, we cannot assume they are speaking without fear.”

Activists argue that even though child marriage is a crime under Pakistani law, courts still validate such marriages, creating a loophole that allows abusers to avoid accountability.

The ruling has drawn strong condemnation. Advocacy groups warn it could lead to more cases like Maria’s, letting vulnerable girls be legally bound to their alleged captors.

They call for urgent reforms: laws voiding child marriages, stronger minority protections, and fair investigations into forced conversion claims.

For now, Maria remains with the man accused of taking her.

Her story has become a symbol for many Pakistani Christians of fear, helplessness, and distrust in a justice system they believe fails them.

Amid pain and uncertainty, many continue to pray for Maria’s safety, for truth, and for justice.

To read more news stories, visit the ICC Newsroom. For interviews, please email [email protected]. To support ICC’s work around the world, please give to our Where Most Needed Fund.